It has been a while since I have posted. There have been so many thoughts and ideas running through my mind, I would start writing and become frustrated. I have finally come to the point were this particular subject is driving me so crazy that I just have to air my opinion.
I am a high school CTE teacher (computers and business). My job is to teach kids real world work skills that will allow them to get a decent paying job right out of high school. I also teach Personal Finance, because after spending 13 years as a stock broker, I realized that to change the declining economy in this nation, we would have to start educating out kids how to manage money and avoid debt BEFORE the dug themselves into a hole. I have chosen to work in an urban school with at risk kids because these are the kids that REALLY need to learn these things. Again, to change the increasing demand on public assistance, you have to give those who have been been raised in that system REAL tools (and real HOPE) to escape.
Many of these kids are a true pain in the behind. They come to me with behavior issues, completely lacking in social skills, and with a chip on their shoulder against the white woman who doesn't understand what they have been through. And I love each one of them desperately. My heart breaks when I hear a student has violated and is going back to jail, when a 14 year old comes to me and tells me she is pregnant with her second child, or when one of my kiddos just gives up and decides it is easier to make money illegally than to finish school and get a real job. I pray for my students on a regular basis and I try to show them the love of Christ in ever interaction. But still, some of these kiddos REALLY try my patience, but I refuse to give up. They would try any teacher's patience, but that does NOT excuse the lack of caring, compassion, and professionalism that I see in the education field ever day!
When I get a 17 year old student that has gone through every grade and he cannot read at a first grade level, there is something SERIOUSLY broken on the system. Education reform is a buzz word that has been used since early in the twentieth century. Everyone has a new idea to try, a new "way" of teaching, a new "plan" to build the students self esteem. Many of the "reforms" we are seeing now are nothing more than repackaged failures from the past. When you challenge "reform", you are called narrow minded, short sighted, and it is said that you "don't care about the children!" You cannot question the newest teaching methods because we have to implement them to see if they work. If they are a failure, well, how could we know until we tried? And the students that were failed by this change? Well, there are always "challenges" whenever we are trying to improve the system. Besides, there is always public assistance to provide for them. Bull pucky!!!!
Here is my plan to rebuild America as THE top nation in innovation and technology, to return our work force to the number one spot in the world, to reclaim the pride and sense of accomplishment that our students have been robbed of for the last 50 plus years.
Do away with age level grades. It is a "stigma". That is why social promotions are so wide spread and 17 year olds can't read. Why should a student that can read at the fourth grade level be forced to stay in first grade reading because they are six? Why should a student who cannot read at the first grade level be promoted to the fourth grade just because he is nine? And why do ALL ten year olds have to be taught the same fifth grade material in all subjects just because that is the age they are? Ever educator will tell you that students have different "intelligences". This is not about an IQ, this is about the ability to learn TYPES of materials and the way they are learned. That 17 year old that can't read? He may be a GENIUS when it comes to math and science. That 12 year old girl that can't figure our fractions? She could be the next Monet. The eight year old that doesn't understand that the world is round may be the next budding Michael Crichton. Many times a child's true potential is never realized because of our current age related grade system with year end promotions to the next level.
We need an ACHIEVEMENT level system. Students should be allowed to move up twice a year, at the winter break (which should probably look more like a college break of four to six weeks) and after the summer break (shorten it up a bit). Students will have levels in ALL areas of learning; math, reading, writing (no more Language Skills crap. Just because you can read doesn't mean you can write and vice versa), science (START with physics!), technology, visual arts, performance arts, geography, social studies/human studies (yes, geography should be separate), economics/personal finance (again, not lumped with "social studies"), life skills, and work readiness skills. Now, before all the PE teachers get ticked, physical education/health/nutrition should be a constant for students from their first day in school until their last, but would be dealt with based more on interests rather than skill level.
In each of the mentioned areas, students would have to reach an 80 percent (yes, 80, not this bologna 60 percent crap) mastery before moving to the next level. If a student masters the first level of math (normally a 2-3 year process, all with the same teacher) in one semester, then at the next break, he can move up to the next level, while staying in the first level for the courses he has not mastered. If a student takes longer to master a certain subject than normal, than a version of RTI would be implemented to make sure she is getting the type and amount of instruction she needs.
In the normal process, MOST students would be able to reach the final level, which would mean they are actually ready for post-secondary education or the workforce, at the age of 16. The students that do this would be able to graduate and leave the public school system if they choose. If they reach the level BEFORE 16, don't force them to stay in school! But for those who WANT to stay in school, they could continue with career focused training through age 21. This would actually involve bringing the community college and technical training system into the public schools, but it would allow students to excel in areas they are good at, while getting the support they need in the areas they are weak in, all without penalizing them for being too good in one area (getting bored with grade level work) and struggling in another (being promoted to the next grade without a firm grasp of the skills needed for the next level).
Diplomas would be awarded depending on the level attained. Students would HAVE to reach the minimum "work readiness" level to get their first diploma. And it would state the level they reached. For students who choose to stay in school beyond the basic level, they would receive diplomas showing the technical certifications or degrees (only to an associates level) that they reached. Also, students who do NOT reach the minimum level, no more letting them drop out at 16. Make kids who have not learned the basics stay in school until they are 18! If they choose to leave at that time, they will receive a certificate of completion for the level they obtained.
Initially, this plan may sound expensive and like a logistics nightmare. The logistics part, I will give you. But as far as cost, I believe it will save money in the long run. Our current system allows students to stay in school through age 21, so the argument that you will have "older" students is a moot point. An equal number of excelling students would be allowed to leave the system at younger ages, freeing up those resources for struggling students. As for the logistics, other countries already have similar systems that work. No need to recreate the wheel; take what works, modify it to fit out needs and move forward.
In my mind, I see 4 "required" levels, roughly representing a break up of our primary, intermediate, middle, and high school system. But no longer would high school be a process of passing the state mandated high stakes test and earning a certain number of credits. There would be a mastery level to be obtained. I can hear people already complaining that students need the "electives" to broaden their knowledge. That is covered by requiring visual arts, performance arts, and adding in the career training pieces. Many of the "electives" are now a required part of learning (drama, band, choir, public speaking=performance arts; drawing, ceramics, graphic design=visual arts; psychology, sociology, child development, criminal justice, law, religious studies=social/human; foods, basic auto, ag, horticulture, sewing, drivers ed=life skills; computers, ACAD, web design, video production=technology; budgeting, economics, managing debt, taxes=personal finance).
My argument with adding these "electives" into required courses is this. EVERY person needs to know how to plan and cook basic meals. EVERY person needs to know how to speak in front of people. EVERY person needs to understand the basics of how their car runs and how to maintain it (even if it is just why and when the oil needs to be changed!). EVERY person should know where our food comes and how to grow their own. EVERY person needs to understand the basics of caring for a child. EVERY person needs to know HOW money works. These are BASIC LIFE SKILLS! A student should not be exempted from learning how to speak in front of people just because they don't take drama or public speaking. Yes, parents SHOULD be teaching things like cooking, caring for kids, managing money, but they DON'T! Even well-adjusted, traditional, middle class students do not have most of these basic skills! If they don't know these things, how are the at risk students ever going to stand a chance.
I do not believe it is the governments job to raise our children. But the fact is that public education is a staple in our country. We need to make the most out of it. We are falling behind other countries in the level of education, the quality of education, and the quality of our work force. America is crumbling because we have been too worried about making sure kids "feel good". Kids aren't as stupid as people believe they are. They KNOW when you are blowing smoke up their butt. Give them REAL skills and achievements that they can be proud of. Instead of graduating students who cannot read, write, or do basic math, make sure they DO have these skills. And give them some real accomplishments to go with it. Okay, so Johnny only gets a certificate for the minimal reading, writing, and math skills, but along with is, he has a certification in auto mechanics that prepares him for a REAL job. He may not be able to name the protagonist in Macbeth or write an argumentative paper on the need for immigration reform, but he CAN read, understand, and apply knowledge from a technical manual. He CAN write a service contract. He CAN speak to a customer in an intelligent and respectful manner.
Let's stop wasting our resources. The children are our future, and with the current education system, the outlook is very bleak. Stop forcing kids to move up to the next level before they have the skills they need just because they are the right age. Stop forcing "college prep" down everyones throat. Not everyone NEEDS or WANTS to go to college, so lets give them some REAL skills in areas they are good in and give them a chance to succeed, rather than setting them up for failure. We graduate students from high school and tell them they are ready to be adults. In the current system, that is a LIE. So, lets change it. Lets focus on really educating students. Lets stop force feeding them material just so they can pass a test, but they have no idea how to apply what they have learned, even if they remember it beyond test day. Give students an opportunity to excel in their strong areas and support them where they are weak. And let those who are ready to move beyond school the chance to do it when they are READY! How many truly brilliant students fail to reach their full potential because they are bored and tired of school by the time they graduate high school, so they go no further? It is time to make a REAL, MEANINGFUL change to our education system. It is time to stop lying to our kids and setting them up for failure. It is time to finally let teachers teach and students learn. It is time.